I met a woman the other day at a business event. In the manner of getting to know one another, we drifted on to the subject of the recent death of her mother. She was slightly uncomfortable about the fact that, despite what she knew was her mother’s unspoken wish that it not happen; she and her siblings had drifted apart over the past year since the “matriarch’s” death. Her mother, like mine, was the glue that held the family together. Without that glue, the fabric of the family was slowly and wordlessly tearing asunder.
I remembered that, as she lay dying, my mother had asked my sisters and brother to stay close. She knew that family was a bond and that we were brought up to believe in our ability to count on each other, especially when there was nobody else around on whom we could count. One of my mom’s expressions was “blood is thicker than water”, signifying the strength of the family bond over other relationships such as marriage or friendship.
Of course, my sisters and I always kidded each other that “Mom loved me the best” and cited various examples of how that was so. Under all of that was a desire to be the favourite child, the golden one in mom’s eyes. When asked, my Mom would also say that she loved us equally. Still, we were ever watchful when Mom paid another of the sister’s special attention, lest our fantasy of being the favourite be shattered.
On occasion, I have wondered whether my three children have felt the same way about my mothering style. Do they feel I have favoured one over the other? Does that create a problem for their relationships with each other or with me? Are there some wrongs that I have done that I should right while I still have the time?
Then I came across this wonderful book called “I’m Still Your Mother”, by Jane Adams. In it, she relates the story where her grown-up son confronts her with the claim that she loved his sister more than him. She offers great advice: When children claim that you loved their siblings more than them, it doesn’t matter what you think or what your truth is. They interpret the past in a way that you can’t change. It’s their truth, their story, and they are sticking to it: “You loved the others more”.
The fact is that we didn’t love our children equally. We loved them differently, because we were different parents to each of them, depending on who we were when they were born, what kind of family environment they were born into, how much they needed us, and how their traits, characteristics, and personalities jibed or clashed with our own. We didn’t treat them equally either. We treated them differently, for the same reasons. And when we face, feel, and communicate that to them, two things happen: We confirm the truth they intuitively know, thus validating their emotional experience, and we provide a context for that experience that frees them to work out their relationship among one another without our interference.
I know that is true of my kids. I was a different person in a different part of my lifetime with each one of them. They each were born into different environments and, in the case of Lynn, into two entirely different families. Each one of them needed me more or less depending on the stage in their life. And they all had different traits and personalities that determined how they interacted with me and how I much I was allowed to demonstrate my love for them.
I know too that the depth and complexity of that love changes as my kids turn into successful and loving adults. I remember when Corey was four years old and he didn’t want to grow because he always wanted to be “my little boy”; he asked me if he could always stay the same size and age. Then at eight years old, as I remarked how much he was growing and reminded him of his wish, he chided me for even thinking that his childhood fantasy was possible – after all, “Everyone has to grow up, Mom, that’s just life”. Fast forward through many years when a hug from his mom was the most embarrassing thing on earth and an “I love you” never graced his lips.
It is New Year’s Eve on the Year 2000 (Y2K). He is leaving the house, all six feet two of him, to go to a party. He walks out the door then comes back in. Walking over to me, he leans down to my height and gives me a hug. He says, “If the world comes to an end tonight, Mom, I want you to know that I love you”.
Now, as Corey learns what it is to be loved as a parent, through the grace of Ayden, not a call or visit goes by where he doesn’t tell me he loves me. Love, full circle.
I didn’t love my children similarly. I loved them differently. Because they were each unique and they each played a different but equally important role in my life. And it was that uniqueness that I loved differently. Love with equity.
However, I’m not giving up on the notion that I was my mother’s favourite ;-)~